« This Just in... | Main | Syria: Assad to address Baath Party Conference. »
A Bedtime Story

Daddy, Whats a GULAG?
Well children, gather ‘round while I tell you a bedtime story of what a “gulag” is.
Once Upon a Time, there was a group of people who lived in a far away land called the “Soviet Union” the people that lived in this fairy tale land were called “ Communists”. Communists were very odd people indeed as they didn’t have castles and palaces, oh no children in fact in the land of communists, Palaces and Castles of all types were forbidden. And to make sure they were forbidden, the leaders of the communists confiscated the very best castles and palaces for their own use, lest their corrupting influences of wealth escape into the general populace.
Now Children, Communists were very odd people indeed. You see, Communists were deathly afraid of anyone who might be able to think for themselves and who might question the wisdom of the communist leaders. So they invented a system, called a corrective labor camp system, known by their Russian initials, G.U.L.A.G.
At first, Gulags were only for special prisoners but over time the system began to be used as a general punishment for any perceived crime against the state. It wasn’t long before the Gulags contained millions of people who were forced into these labor camps for the smallest of crimes and most arbitrary requirements by the leaders of the Communists. People were abused, tortured and forced into hard labor for decades at a time with no hope of eventually being freed. Rather than being allowed to go free at the end of their sentence, many prisoners were killed by firing squad.
While a person was a prisoner in the Gulag, they had no rights, no privileges, no access to legal staff or any rights to appeal their convictions. They were guaranteed no condition of their incarceration. They were housed in conditions that were less than that used for farm animals because children, to the Communists, that’s just what they were, animals, beast of burden to be used and thrown away at the behest of the communist leaders.
“But Dad, what happened to the Gulags?” said the little kid.
Well, one day a man named Ronald Reagan came along and he called the communists an “evil empire” and set the country on a path that would not cater to or accept the communists any longer. Unlike many of his predecessors, he didn’t want to learn to live with communists in peaceful coexistence, he wanted to see them and their nightmare reign of terror put to an end. Many people gasped at the rudeness of his statements and positions towards the Communists but those who were incarcerated behind the wires of the gulags thanked God that someone finally understood the evil that they have lived with for years. Then, all of a sudden and in the blink of an eye, the communists gave up as they finally realized that they had no hope to succeed in beating the west now that they had been exposed for the evil that they truly were.
“So, millions of people were put into communist labor and reeducations camps, tortured and then systematically exterminated to support an evil system that put the rights of the state over the people it governed and that was suppressing the rights of its very own citizens as a regular course of governmental action?” said the kid.
“Yes son, that’s correct” said Dad with an air of exasperation.
“So, if you don’t mind my asking dad, just what the heck was Irene Khan talking about when she said the United States is running the Gulag of our times. Doesnt the fact that she could say that without any fear of incarceration prove that she is full of it?" questioned the kid.
Well son, there are some things that a person is required to believe if they are to get into the right kinds of parties in Hollywood and Washington D.C. If your in an organization that makes its money from the gin soaked checkbooks of holier than thou liberal types, who frankly liked the Communists anyway and agreed with their methods no matter how murderous and harsh, then there is no better way to generate cash than to accuse the United States Government of the very crimes that dictatorships and communists have been doing all along. Youre just not going to generate alot of cash from those people if you stand up and say " Fidel Castro is the warden of a prison called Cuba ". Now if you say "Bush is Hitler" Checkbooks start popping open pretty fast.
You see, according to those people, The United States was really no better than the Soviet Union anyway, and to them, this is just proof of that idea. I guess that idea just helps them sleep better at night.
“Dad?”
“Yes my son?”
“Do you think people still eat lead paint chips?”
“Yes I do. Apparently they are served fairly regularly and in large doses at Amnesty International Fundraisers”.
Update: The Great Babalu tells-it-like-it-is.
Posted @ June 02, 2005 12:43 AM | Current Affairs
This is an outstanding post. I have been trying to formulate some sort of a coherent explanation as to why the parallel between the GULAG and U.S.-run detention facilities for captive terrorists, but found myself increasingly tongue-tied by the sheer magnitude of the fallacy (see website). Kudos to the author for finding a tasteful, yet scathing way to expose it for what it is.
Posted by: E.K.
at June 2, 2005 06:43 PM
I think what most infuriates me about Amnesty saying such a horrid thing is that there are people alive today who are survivors of the gulag who are being marginalized by this kind of thing. soviet gulags were real and they were real horrible places where atrocities occured. But there are still gulags today, in places like North Korea and China. Not a word is said about the Soviet Gulags or the existing ones in existance today. Rather than do something about the millions in real gulags, Amnesty internation is aghast at roughly 700 prisoners in Cuba, where they will leave Cuba having put on wieght, had their relgious views respected and their diet will be tailored to their nationalities.
Its offensive to me to think of people who are alive today who survived the gulags in siberia having to listen to this crap. It bothers me because Amnesty internation was once a good organization that was interested in accomplishing a noble goal.
Those days Im afraid are long gone.
Posted by: varifrank
at June 2, 2005 07:39 PM



![Validate my RSS feed [Valid RSS]](http://varifrank.com/images/valid-rss.png)